Comparing Ashland and Columbia, MO: Which Community Suits You Best?

Cheryl Maupin
|
March 10, 2025

Overview

Ashland, Missouri—population hovering near 5,000—remains a smallish town caught between farmland roots and the pull of nearby Columbia’s city sprawl. Real estate? Prices have been creeping up, but you might still snag a modest home under $300k if you’re lucky. People keep moving in because it’s close to bigger job centers while still holding that “rural quiet.” Meanwhile, Columbia—with around 125,000 folks—anchors the region: it’s got the University of Missouri, a big medical scene, and a growing tech presence. Home prices can range widely; older bungalows near downtown get snapped up fast, while suburban developments easily breach the mid-$300k range. Both towns are seeing more newcomers, drawn by that “Missouri is cheaper than the coasts” promise. If you’re torn between cozy Ashland and the energy of Columbia, let’s crack it open.

Cost of Living

Overall, neither place is going to scorch your wallet like a coastal city, but there’s a gap. Ashland historically has lower home prices—some older ranches or new builds at prices that might make a Californian do a double-take. Groceries and daily expenses are typical for rural-ish Missouri—relatively chill. But remember, you might commute to Columbia or Jefferson City for bigger stores or job hubs, so factor in gas.

Columbia, bigger and more diverse, can have cheaper groceries (bulk discount from bigger retail?), but housing’s a different beast. Near Mizzou or downtown, you can pay a premium. Newer suburban areas might feel more “middle-of-the-road.” Utilities can be up there thanks to that Midwest weather roller coaster (AC all summer, heat all winter). In short, Ashland might save you on housing, but Columbia gives you more range—just watch out for those neighborhoods near campus that can spike your rent or property taxes.

Job Market

Ashland itself doesn’t host major corporations. It’s more bedroom community—people drive up or down Highway 63 to get to work in Columbia or Jefferson City. If you work remote or run your own small business, the small-town vibe might be fine, but big job opportunities are typically out of town. Some local shops or services exist, but don’t expect a corporate park.

Columbia benefits from Mizzou, the university hospital system, and a rising tech scene. Healthcare, education, plus some state government spillover—these are big draws. If you’re chasing a stable job, Columbia’s more likely to deliver. There’s also a decent startup vibe around downtown, coworking spaces, etc. Downside? More competition, and traffic can snarl at times (though nothing like major metros). Ultimately, if you want local job variety, Columbia’s your bet. If a quiet homestead with a commute is fine, Ashland might still suit you.

Entertainment

Ashland: Quieter Than Quiet

  • Local Eateries & Bars
    Not a huge scene. You might find a couple of diners, a pizza joint, maybe a local bar for that Friday night unwind. If you crave more variety, you’re driving. People in Ashland typically bounce up to Columbia for big nights out.
  • Parks & Outdoors
    You’ll find local parks, farmland vistas, and small-town events—like maybe a fall festival or a 4th of July shindig. If you’re outdoorsy, you might trek to Rock Bridge State Park or the Missouri River near Jeff City.
  • Community Highlights
    This is more about local holiday parades, high school sports, and neighborly gatherings. Ashland thrives on that “everyone knows your name” vibe.

Columbia: College Town Energy

  • Restaurants & Bars
    Downtown Columbia is a mini foodie haven: from craft beers at Logboat Brewing or Flat Branch to late-night cravings at Insomnia Cookies. Bars along 9th Street or the District serve the college crowd and locals alike.
  • Music & Arts
    With Mizzou in the mix, live music pops up often—rock shows at The Blue Note, open mics at coffee shops, the True/False Film Fest for documentary lovers. The city invests in cultural events, so there’s always something on the calendar.
  • Sports & Outdoors
    Mizzou Tigers football is a big deal if you’re into college sports. Plus, the Katy Trail for biking, a labyrinth of city parks, and nature spots like Rock Bridge Memorial State Park for hikes and cave explorations.
  • Nightlife
    Bars stay open late, especially around campus, but it’s not an all-night rave scene. Still, you get a healthy variety of brewpubs, clubs, and live music venues if you’re chasing more lively nights than you’d get in Ashland.

In summary: If you want immediate access to bars, restaurants, events, you’ll lean Columbia. If a quiet after-dinner walk around the block is enough nightlife for you, Ashland is your calm corner—just be prepared to drive for bigger excitements.

Education

Ashland is served by the Southern Boone County School District—smaller, known for a close-knit environment, decent test scores, and that small-town high school football vibe. People rave about the teacher-to-student ratio and community support. For advanced programs, you might have fewer options than a bigger district, but some families love that personal touch.

Columbia has the Columbia Public Schools, one of the state’s larger districts. Quality can vary by neighborhood—some high schools rank well in the region, while others might struggle. There’s a boatload of private and charter schools around, too, if you want to pay for smaller class sizes or specialized curricula. Then there’s Mizzou—the University of Missouri, a research-heavy campus fueling the city’s intellectual vibe. Also, Columbia College and Stephens College are in town, offering diverse higher ed options. Ashland folks who want advanced classes or specialized programs might end up commuting to or tapping into Columbia’s resources, so keep that in mind if you have kids in secondary or post-secondary transitions.

The Vibes

Ashland:

  • Slow-paced, definitely more rural. If you like the idea of farmland meeting budding subdivisions, a couple of grocery stores, local diners, and that sense of knowing your neighbors’ names, Ashland’s in your lane. It’s the “drive 15 minutes to bigger civilization” trade-off. Housing might be easier to manage price-wise, and you get that small-town Americana thing going on.

Columbia:

  • College-town spunk meets Midwestern city. You’ll see a swirl of students, professors, creatives, and professionals in one pot. More restaurants, more nightlife, more job variety, but also more traffic, higher home prices in prime spots, and the hustle of a city on the grow. If you need energy, events, and you prefer not to drive for your entertainment, Columbia’s your jam.

Ultimately, Ashland is for people who want that quieter life but with the ability to hop onto Highway 63 and hit up big-box stores or Mizzou football when they feel like it. Columbia suits those who want immediate access to cultural events, a range of dining, and a sense of urban hustle (by Missouri standards anyway).

Wrapping Up

So, Ashland vs. Columbia: one’s your classic small-town neighbor of the big city, where new homes keep popping up but the farmland vibe lingers; the other’s the region’s hub, fueled by Mizzou, breweries, music festivals, and a steady population churn. Both share that central Missouri climate (get ready for hot, humid summers and unpredictable winters), but differ in daily pace, housing markets, and nightlife. If you crave simplicity and don’t mind driving to the city for more than the basics, Ashland might satisfy. If you want the city swirl, job variety, and a college-town pulse, Columbia’s your stage. Either way, you’re in mid-MO territory—enjoy the sweet tea, rolling hills, and that genuine neighborly spirit.

FAQs

  1. Is housing really cheaper in Ashland than Columbia?
    Generally, yes. Smaller market, slightly lower average home prices. But new developments can still push up costs.
  2. How’s the commute from Ashland to Columbia?
    Usually 15–20 minutes on Highway 63, not bad by city standards. You’ll do it regularly if you want bigger stores or entertainment.
  3. Which has better schools—Ashland’s Southern Boone or Columbia Public Schools?
    Both have solid reputations. Ashland’s is smaller and more personal. Columbia offers bigger variety and advanced programs.
  4. Does Ashland have any nightlife at all?
    Not really—maybe a local bar or diner. Serious nightlife or bigger restaurants mean heading to Columbia.
  5. Is Columbia super busy with college traffic?
    It can be, especially near campus. During Mizzou’s session, the city feels busier, and game days can snarl traffic.
  6. What about property taxes?
    They vary by county, but generally, Boone County’s rates are consistent across towns. City taxes in Columbia might push a bit higher than in Ashland.
  7. Which city is more family-friendly?
    Both can be. Ashland’s small-town environment suits families who want close-knit vibes; Columbia has more amenities, parks, and extracurriculars. You choose the pace that fits you.

Request a FREE Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Brokered By:
Contact Us
700 Cherry St Suite E, Columbia, MO 65201